Saturday, April 26, 2008

Digestive Biscuits


Digestive biscuits are one of our most popular commercially-baked biscuit varieties - the chocolate-coated version gets wolfed down in the UK at a rate of 52 biscuits a second, according to the website of United Biscuits, one of the major producers. Don’t look at me. I can probably only manage that level over the course of a full minute.

According to United Biscuits’ website; ‘The first ever digestive biscuit was created by a new young employee, Alexander Grant [in 1892 according to a United Biscuit’s Press Release, but this site, dates the biscuit to 1839]. The name Digestive was derived from its high content of baking soda as an aid to food digestion.’ This idea that baking soda aided digestion is contemporary with creation of the biscuit, and manufacturers no longer make any such claim.

As an aside, Mrs Beeton writing in 1861 says of biscuits; ‘Biscuits belong to the class of unfermented bread, and are, perhaps, the most wholesome of that class. In cases where fermented bread does not agree with the human stomach, they may be recommended: in many instances they are considered lighter, and less liable to create acidity and flatulence.’ No wonder we are such a nation of biscuit eaters (without flatulence... possibly).

The gentleman United Biscuits credits for creating the digestive biscuit worked for a Scottish bakery called McVitie & Price Ltd., founded in Edinburgh in 1830. In 1948 the company merged with another Scottish family bakery, Macfarlane, Lang & Co., Ltd., to become United Biscuits Group. Mcvitie’s name lives on as a United Biscuits’ brand, and it is the name generally synonymous with digestive biscuits in UK supermarkets - although there are many rival brands, plus supermarket-own versions.

A competing claim for the first digestive comes from another Edinburgh biscuit manufacturer. Robert Middlemass set up Middlemass’ Biscuit Factory in 1835. By 1896 production was mechanised and Middlemass produced the famous ‘Albert Biscuit’ during Queen Victoria’s reign (click here for a recipe) but the achievement he was proudest of was the ‘invention’of the digestive biscuit [sorry, I couldn’t find a date for this one]. The factory closed in 1974.

The chocolate digestive biscuit was first produced by Mcvitie & Price in 1925. They named it the ‘Homewheat Chocolate Digestive’ because the wheat used in the biscuit was grown in Britain, at a time when competitors were using imported ingredients. It was therefore (and still is) a proudly British biscuit - although perhaps the Scots should really get the lion’s share of the credit for coming up with the idea in the first place. Incidentally, it is only in the last few years that ‘Homewheat’ has been dropped from the packaging of the Mcvitie’s Chocolate Digestive after a rebrand, although a scan around the internet suggests that exported biscuits still carry this name - check out the ‘product features’ for a chocolate digestive on Amazon.com!. Don’t laugh, I think ‘snack’ , ‘teatime’,’easy dessert’ and not to mention ‘made in England’ are very important selling points.

In ‘The Oxford Companion to Food’ (Ed. Alan Davidson), Laura Mason describes the digestive biscuit as being, ‘of the pastry flour type, made from coarse brown flour. It is thick, fairly crisp, but also crumbly and, being only moderately sweet, goes well with hard English cheese. The biscuit has no particularly digestive properties and is banned for sale under that name in the USA. Alternative names are ‘wheatmeal’ and ‘sweetmeal’. Recipes for home-made digestives generally include oatmeal to give the required texture.’

I found various digestive biscuit recipes on my shelves. The earliest is from a book published in 1902 (The Queen Newspaper Cookery book series, No. 11 - Bread, cakes and biscuits, collected and described by S. Beaty-Pownall), reproduced in Andre Simon’s ‘Cereals’ (pub. 1943):

'Rub 1 lb. of butter into 5 lb.of wheatmeal; make a hollow in the centre and pour into this 4 lightly beaten up eggs, with 4 oz. sugar and 1/4 oz. of carbonate of soda; mix this all to a little pool of batter in the centre of the flour, then gradually draw down the latter from the sides with a circular motion of your fingers, moistening the dough this produced with about 1 quart of water, added by degrees, till you get it all to a nice workable consistency. Take up one-third of this dough and roll it out to the thickness of a penny; spread a clean cloth on the kitchen table; lift the dough on to the rolling-pin and roll it out again on the cloth, then cut out into oval or round cakes, prick these and place them in the oven. Finish off the rest of the dough in the same way.'

No baking temperatures or times given.

For cooking up commercial quantities (though not a batch to rival McVitie’s) you could turn to the recipe in ‘The Baker’s Repository of Recipes’, published in the late 1940s, and part of a collection of recipes representing Scotland’s bakery industry prior to 1939:

6 lb. soft flour
3 1/2 lb. wheatmeal
1/2 lb. oatmeal
2 1/2 oz. soda
2 1/2 oz. cream powder
1 1/2 lb. butter
1 1/2 lb. pure lard
4 oz. glucose
1 1/2 oz. salt
1 1/2 lb. sugar
22 oz. water

Rub fat finely through flour and make all into a dough. Allow the dough to rest, then run down through rollers. Cut out, preferably with a combination cutter. Lay on wires and bake. The dough is usually passed through rollers in canvas sheets.

This second recipe uses a combination of different flours and adds fats to the mix. It looks not too far removed from the content of today’s supermarket biscuits, but I fancied baking something a little homelier (and smaller in proportions).

110g/4 oz. medium oatmeal [I used fine oatmeal as that was already in the cupboard. By all means try medium, but I think fine will prevent the biscuit feeling too much like chipboard]
35g/1 1/2 oz. caster sugar
110g/4 oz. wholemeal flour
75g/3 oz. butter
A pinch of salt
A small pinch of bicarbonate of soda
1/2 egg

Rub butter into flour and oatmeal, add sugar, salt and soda. Bind with the beaten egg, put the dough on pastry-board sprinkled with oatmeal, and roll out. Sprinkle lightly with oatmeal, roll it in, and then cut in oval shapes. Bake in a tin in a fairly hot oven.

Recipe from ‘Farmhouse Fare - Country Recipes collected by 'Farmers Weekly’, published 1973.

(N.B. The Reader’s Digest 'Farmhouse Cookery - Recipes from the Country Kitchen', carries an almost identical recipe under the name ‘Digestion Biscuits’. The text state; 'As their name suggests, Digestion Biscuits were considered good for the stomach. Certainly, the Victorians thought so, and the biscuits - made with oatmeal and wholemeal flour - were popular in many country households.

Digestions Biscuits were sometimes eaten as an alternative to bread. They are excellent with butter and cheese.'
)

It was this second recipe that I used for my biscuits. I used an oven temperature of 190C, and baked for 12-14 minutes. The observant among you will spot that I dipped one face of my biscuits into dark chocolate. Well, I had to really. I did try one or two undressed biscuits, and very nice they were too, but it would have been clear foolishness not to also have tried them with chocolate.


As a point of comparison, I purchased two packs of commercially made digestives. Everyone and their aunt produce their own brand of digestives, so I chose Doves Wholewheat Digestives as Doves make the point of stating on their packaging that the biscuits are ‘Made with English Wheat’; and I selected Nairns Oat Digestives as Nairns are an Edinburgh based Scottish bakery, plus the inclusion of oats made the recipe similar to the one I baked from.


This may have placed them at a disadvantage, but neither of the other two sets of biscuit had any chocolate anywhere about them...


The biscuit tasting was carried out by myself and my junior kitchen hand. In Ellis' honest opinion they were all much of a muchness, and all samples disappeared into his tasting hatch at a fast rate. I tried him with a cheese laden biscuit, but this proved unpopular and was quickly ejected from the tasting hatch. For myself, I found the commercial biscuits dryer and crisper, with a firmer 'bite'. I couldn't discern the flavour of honey in the Nairns biscuit, and found the Doves biscuit was of similar subtle sweetness. Both stood up well to a dunking in a cup of tea (a very traditional method of consumption). My home-baked digestives had an easier texture, more crumble about them and were more interesting in the mouth. I had been concerned that the home-made biscuits would end up a little penitential - obviously, the chocolate coating helped - but they were tasty and far removed from a dry cardboard state.


Go on, you deserve a cup of tea and a biscuit...

49 comments:

Lael said...

just what I was looking for! my friend's birthday is coming up and since we share so many fond memories of late night snacks of tea and chocolate digestives while studying for a semester in Oxford, I wanted to recreate them for her. I've visited your site several times to reminisce about England and enjoy every one of your posts. thank you!

Joanna said...

Very interesting post, and your digestives look much nicer than either of those from the packets. Even without the chocolate ;)

Joanna

K said...

Hmmm. I am intrigued by the revelation that Nairn's make digestives, as I live along the road from the Nairn's factory and often breathe in their baking smell as I cycle past. But I've never seen the digestives for sale (although their oatcakes are all over the place).

Yours look nicer - with a good generous covering of chocolate!

Karen said...

I live in Edinburgh and went often as a child (not so very long ago!) to McVitie's restaurant/cafe (a place of several floors and different types of eating establishments, if I remember correctly). Digestive biscuits may well have been served along with 'fancy cakes' on three tier stands, all brought to the table by waitresses in black dresses and crisp white aprons.
In "The World according to Bertie", Alexander McCall Smith mentions the house in which the inventor of the digestive biscuit lived, and goes on to say that another Edinburgh street is associated with "baking distinction" as it was home to the creator of the Jaffa cake!
Your biscuits look very good and would no doubt go down well up here.

Lysy said...

What a lovely post. I've dallied with the idea of making these for a while but was worried about the 'penitential' aspect as well - good to know they turned out better than the commercial ones! I love the chocolate topping, too - will definitely be giving them a try

London Foodie said...

I have been trying to develop a good digestive recipe forever! I cannot wait to try these! Thanks. www.londonfoodieny.wordpress.com

Anonymous said...

Thank you for doing this Anna. I will try the recipe tomorrow and fingers crossed mine will look as good as yours. I'll let you know!
Karin

edamame said...

I am interested in the food culture of your country. And I support your site. If there is time, please come in my site.
From Japan
http://food-soybean.blogspot.com/

Rosie said...

Just what is needed with a lovely cuppa one or two of your biscuits!! They look delish :)

Rosie x

7tourvercors said...

Hello ! I've just tried and taste your recipe (the second one - less sugar, more oatflour)... And It is just delicious ! It's quiet difficult to find such biscuits in France so thank you, Now I can do it :)

And thank you too for your nice blog.

Emilie

anna said...

Thanks for the kind comments. I shall be making these again, not least because they appear to be better for my junior taster than the shop bought alternatives. Lael - hope your birthday digestives brought back a memory or two, Proustian-style. Karen - I am intrigued by the idea of a McVitie's restuarant/'posh' cafe. Does this still exist?

Clumbsy Cookie said...

What a great post! I've visited your blog a couple of times since I'm very interested in british desserts.
I love this kind of cookies, when I lived in the UK I used to eat a package or 2 a week, they're such a godd way to "eat" tea or coffee.
I will defenitly make these at home, they looked so good! What did you mean by wholemeal? I'm guessing it's whole wheat flour.
Thanks for the great post again!

Anonymous said...

Great posting! We just returned from England yesterday (May 30) and had a marvelous time. On the flight back to the States, we ate packaged Oat & Wholemeal biscuits from our last bed and breakfast stay. The name on the package is Brake Bros Ltd. We really enjoyed them which led me to look for a recipe and, thus, I found this site. Wish I found it prior to our trip.

Anyhow, I will give the recipe a try. I'm excited! The chocolate touch sounds great too.

Quick question...for that 1/2 egg, did you just beat it and measure half from that?

Thanks again! Chris

Jennifer A. Wickes said...

I am American, but grew up for a quite a few years in Bermuda. I used to eat McVities' digestives. They were fabulous! Of course, now that I am older, I have been looking for a recipe I can make and this one is fantastic. Thanks for such a great blog!

Food Pursuit

tastefultart said...

Hi there,
I found your entry via google after I looked for digestive biscuit links for my latest blog entry. Interesting post, thank you. I just added a link to this from my blog.
Johanna.

Maria Rosario Read said...

Hello there!
I'm not English, I'm from Argentina, I have lot of great memories of when I was a child in Japan, I basically grew up with them....
I got nostalgic and decided to bake "a homemade batch" ...and came across your entry.

I try these, thanks!!

Katie Scarlett said...

I tried these once (I'm from Virginia, U.S.) and they taste a lot like our graham crackers over here, except crumblier.

betty said...

Wonderful , beautiful , INSPIRING blogsite-I love the pictures!!! Thank you!Betty http://www.geothermalquestions.net

Anonymous said...

Ah! Ive been baking digestives all morning..... and then came across your lovely post. Yours look delicious. Ive added your site to my links, hope thats ok, my site is giespeas.wordpress.com if you want a look.

square dinnerware said...

52 per second eh?

Anyone up for a race? :)

Thanks for the recipe!

Elizeth said...

Excellent Post ! I Love this.

Elizabeth said...

hi.
great presentation, excellent tips.

Claire said...

You know, I thinks this may be the coolest baking site on the entire web! And what a fantastic recipe for Suggestive, I mean DIgestive Biccies. Thank you so much :)

basooma said...

you're such a nice cooker thanks

Nicci said...

What is 'cream powder' and what can I use as a substitute if it is not available here in the states. I'm dying to try your recipe! :)

Ladyhihi said...

Very interesting post, and your digestives look much nicer than either of those from the packets. Even without the chocolate ;)


sajoo
pokerturneringar

Hampers said...

These look yum I am all for bicuits that are made slightly healthier!

Alana Johns said...

I've tried these and I have to say they are the best chocolate biscuits in the whole world!! I made the second version with less sugar and with oatmeal and, naturally, with a generous covering of chocolate to finish off. I urge EVERYONE to make a batch, you'll never eat shop chocolate biscuits again!

cuongthao said...

online bingo bonus

ดูบอลออนไลน์r a semester in Oxford, I wanted to recreate them for her. I've visited your site several times to reminisce about England and enjoy every one

Bingo said...

Excellent Post ! I Love this.

Online Bingo said...

We always have biscuits after church and this has always been a problem in my family. Especially after we are done playing a game of online bingo.

infoengineering said...

Infoengineering is the manufacturer of biscuit dies which are made high quality gun metal and not plastic. Most popular biscuit machine. Can make twenty types of biscuits. Original biscuit forms can be made directly on the baking tray with the dies provided. Made of pure aluminum to guarantee long life.

For more details visit us:
http://www.infoengineering.in/products.html

infoengineering said...

Infoengineering has designed and constructed our own specialized machinery to ensure high quality and cost-efficient production of Rollers and Inserts because each roller is made to customers requirements.

For More Details visit us:
http://www.infoengineering.in

infoengineering said...

Infoengineering is widely engaged in manufacturing and supplying machinery for contemporary but relishing biscuits. We are offering very cost effective and long lasting equipment so that these machinery give out optimum production.


For More Details visit us:
http://www.infoengineering.in

infoengineering said...

Infoengineering is widely engaged in manufacturing and supplying machinery for contemporary but relishing biscuits. We are offering very cost effective and long lasting equipment so that these machinery give out optimum production.


For More Details visit us:
http://www.infoengineering.in

infoengineering said...

Infoengineering offers the complete package for all your biscuit & snack cutting and moulding rollers. When you contact infoengineering , takes the notes, produces your exclusive designs and controls all aspects of the roller manufacture, including final inspection and prompt dispatch.


For More Details visit us:
http://www.infoengineering.in

infoengineering said...

Infoengineering is a leading manufacturer & exporter of rotary biscuit cutting machine. Also Engaged in manufacturing and exporting of biscuit cutters that includes rotary biscuit cutter, automatic biscuit cutter machines, cake biscuit cutter machines and commercial biscuit cutter machines.

For more details visit us:
http://www.infoengineering.in/products.html

infoengineering said...

Biscuit dies manufacturers

Infoengineering has designed and constructed our own specialized machinery to ensure high quality and cost-efficient production of Rollers and Inserts because each roller is made to customers requirements.

For More Details visit us:
http://www.infoengineering.in

infoengineering said...

Infoengineering is manufacturer of biscuit moulds and dies which are made high quality gun metal and not plastic. We have supplied die rollers of various sizes using high quality gunmetal. With following salient features: We are using latest pantograph machines for engraving which provide accurate relieve angle to the die cavity, enhancing release capability of the die.

For more details visit us:
http://www.infoengineering.in/products.html

infoengineering said...

Infoengineering has designed and constructed our own specialized machinery to ensure high quality and cost-efficient production of Rollers and Inserts because each roller is made to customers requirements.

For More Details visit us:
http://www.infoengineering.in

infoengineering said...

Infoengineering is the Exporter, manufacturer and supplier of biscuits cutting die roller, biscuit plant, biscuit machine, biscuit manufacturing plant, biscuit making plant...food processing plants, food processing machinery, biscuit manufacturing plant.


For more details visit us:
http://www.infoengineering.in

infoengineering said...

Infoengineering is manufacturer of biscuit dies which are made high quality. We have supplied die rollers of various sizes. Used for making different varieties of biscuits such as cream filled plain wafers and several others, our range can manufacture biscuits in large quantities. These can be customized as per the requirements of our clients.

For more details visit us:
http://www.infoengineering.in

infoengineering said...

Infoengineering offers the complete package for all your biscuit & snack cutting and moulding rollers. When you contact infoengineering , takes the notes, produces your exclusive designs and controls all aspects of the roller manufacture, including final inspection and prompt dispatch.


For More Details visit us:
http://www.infoengineering.in

infoengineering said...

Infoengineering offer different kinds of Biscuit moulding, Biscuit cutting dies and Biscuit Die Roller as per the requirements of our clients. These are fabricated as per industry recommendations and international quality standard norms, and are demanded for easy operation, user friendliness, low maintenance and high efficiency.


For More Details visit us:
http://www.infoengineering.in530 tinuinte

Sunny Kathuria said...

Get to know the best of Online Bingo Sites on the internet.

Benitto said...

Read useful information and reviews for digestive health products http://www.the-healthiest.com/archives/category/health-products/digestive-health

bcrocks said...

I could not get the link to the recipe for cookies made by the Middlemass Biscuit Co. If anyone has it.......I would love to see it. Rumour has it that my family was related to Robert Middlemass...so I am trying to find any info that I can. If anyone has any info please e-mail me at hallheather94@yahoo.ca Thanks

Anmol Biscuits said...

Anmol is a well-known name among the Biscuit Manufacturers in India. In sync with the traits of a Top Biscuit Manufacturer, Anmol pays complete attention to the quality control steps, thereby ensuring that the consumers receive only the best quality products.

http://www.anmolbiscuits.com/

Addison Lee said...

Exporter of biscuits, milk biscuits, glucose biscuits, coconut biscuits, honey biscuits, cream biscuits, ginger biscuits etc.

Biscuit Exporters India